The Fifth Starter…

     Four spots in the Red Sox rotation are locked up, and all four pitchers are of quality.  But there is still one spot remaining that is yet to be filled.  There are options outside of the organization: Derek Lowe, who I would expect to be roughly league average and durable for the next four years.  But Lowe would also command a rather hefty price.  Ben Sheets, who signed to a two-year deal would be wise, most likely, but Sheets may find someone to give him more than two years, which I personally would stay away from (one year of Sheets would be even better, but two would be fine too).  Brad Penny, who could be this years Bartolo Colon, except much more upside.  Penny would be a nice addition for a year, but anything more than that, which isn’t built on the basis of a team option, would be too much.  John Smoltz, whom I have absolutely no idea where he would pitch, or even if he would pitch (health).  But if any team gives him a one year deal, at a relatively cheap price, it would be a good decision. 

     But the Red Sox have even more attractive in house options, in addition to the ones above that are out-of-house.  Clay Buchholz is definitely one of them.  That curve, That change, and that fastball in which he can work the other pitches off, brings much intrigue.  Clay is the most appealing pitcher, because he has the most talent in the organization (outside of established starters).  But as we learned from last year, from the likes of both Buchholz and Phil Hughes, one does not necessarily know what to expect from a young starter, even with great stuff.  Although I do have confidence that eventually, Clay will put it together and be, if nothing else, a capable starter.  But limiting his innings and having another starter penciled in may be the best thing for not only Buccholz, but the team.  Then if he makes some strides in the minors, again, then they can move him into the rotation.

     Another option is to let Justin Masterson return to the rotation where he was present for a few starts in the middle of 2008.  Via Keith Law, the only scout I read, he has stated that Masterson lacks an effective out-pitch to lefties and opposing teams could stack the lineup accordingly.  But of course, maybe Masterson can learn how to retire left-handed hitters a little more efficiently.  I don’t know that he develops another pitch, but maybe tailors his sinker a tad more to get them to keep the ball on the ground more often.  And I am guessing location would have a lot to do with that.  So, easier said than done…  Last season, in a rather small sampling, and a partial split of time between the bullpen and the rotation, Masterson’s splits went like this. 

Vs. RH hitters:  .196/.274/.298

Vs. LH hitters:  .238/.365/.422

     As one can see from those numbers, Masterson has some issues against left handed hitters, although he was very good against RH hitters.  Going into the season, or more accurately, Masterson moving up to the majors, questions were raised about how Masterson had many more troubles the second and third time through a lineup.  Which is another reason that many wanted to see him in the pen.  And these questions are legitimate and contain some accuracy.  But Masterson is certainly capable of performing as a fifth starter, most likely better (4?), if Theo chooses to want to save a lot of money, particularly on avoiding a pitcher such as Derek Lowe. 

     But if Masterson shifts to the five man crew, then someone will need to take over his spot in the bullpen.  Ramon Ramirez should be decent.  Okajima should be too.  Either could be above average without doing too much.  And there are a few pitchers in the minors that could potentially come up and throw some relief innings if needed.  The Red Sox may even find another way to bring in a reliever, via trade, or free agency.  Preferably just a short term contract, low risk, if they choose the free agency route.

     There are options, there are choices, and Theo has a lot to do with that.  But avoiding a large contract is the best thing they can do, I believe.  Sabathia would have been one thing, but Lowe is another.  Derek Lowe is a solid pitcher, but it is much easier to find someone close to what Lowe is, and at a club-friendly cost (although Lowe would not be a bad signing).  So whether it be Masterson, Buchholz, or Penny, the Sox can fill out the rotation, and the “depth of the rotation” without spending fifteen million a year.       


I’d like to keep Masterson in the bullpen, he was such a relief to have during the post season. Okajima-Masterson-Papelbon or Masterson-Okajima-Papelbon was always reliable. And now that we have Ramirez in the mix, we do have some flexibility. I like the Brad Penny/Bartolo Colon comparison. Derek Lowe is very appealing, but if his price went down, like you said, it’d be even better. Then the Mets would get in on him as well, and it’d be another offseason battle between the Mets and Red Sox. It’ll be interesting to see what goes down with Teixeria.


Derek Lowe has stated that he wants to return to the Red Sox; so, he would be a good option as the fifth starter … But, if they don’t sign any other pitchers, Clay Buchholz would also be a solid choice as the fifth starter … As for the Yankees, there have been reports that there is still a good chance that Andy Pettitte will re-sign with the Yanks … And, the Yankees still have an interest in signing Derek Lowe … Those pitchers would be the Yankees best options as their fifth starter … Also, of note, the Yankees are no longer interested in signing Ben Sheets because they are concerned about some back injuries he has had … Anyway, I think, the fifth starter for both the Yankees and Red Sox will be decided in “spring training” !!! … Jimmy [27NYY]

Lowe would be a decent option, but back in the AL East, and for a lot of money…while lets just say I wouldn’t mind going with someone on the farm. Although I would not mind going with Lowe as the Red Sox have a good defense, and Lowe IS a sinkerball pitcher. I would rather have Tex, but again who wouldn’t?

Out here in CA, they weren’t too crazy about Penny. Seems he was injured a lot and didn’t have a good “attitude.” Lowe would be a better fit, no? He certainly knows how to pitch at Fenway.

But one year of Penny, vs. four years of Lowe. And there are two pitchers who could start if they improve enough, or shift to the rotation (Buchholz and Masterson). Penny would just be a depth acquisition and I personally would not go more than a single year on him.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: